The report that Alice Huang may have held stakes in businesses that benefited Huawei while she was in business with Nvidia is serious enough that it should not be waved away. According to CNBC, analysts at Tesari traced a chain of corporate records and media reports linking Huang, whose Chinese name is Huang Le, to entities that provided computing power to Huawei. The timing matters. Businesses connected to her were linked with supplying Nvidia computing power to Huawei around December 2023, the same period in which she and Jensen Huang were first publicly seen together.
The evidence presented so far is a set of interlocking transactions, not a finding of wrongdoing. Huang sold a cloud business called Osmanthus to 7Road in 2019, and a 7Road subsidiary was later spun off as Megaspeed, which The Information reported helped facilitate at least $7.5 billion in Nvidia chip shipments to Chinese firms. Through Shanghai Hexi, Huang was connected to a data center called Shenzhen Yifeng Technology, whose key customer was Huawei Cloud. CNBC reported that it is not clear whether that data center acquired Nvidia GPUs. Those gaps should be stated plainly, not filled with assumptions.
Still, the questions raised are legitimate. Tesari's Brian Andersen said the activity warrants a national security and counterproliferation investigation, and he named possible charges such as export-control violations, conspiracy and smuggling if investigators found controlled equipment was transferred to Huawei without authorization. Tesari analysts also told CNBC they suspect the structure was designed to obscure the relationship. Whether that suspicion holds is a matter for the Commerce Department's Bureau of Industry Security and Homeland Security Investigations, not for a column or a private intelligence firm.
Jensen Huang has acknowledged an affair, though the timing is unknown, and nothing in the report establishes that he knew his partner was tied to his competitor's supply chain. That is precisely why Nvidia should say what it knew and when. Nvidia and Huawei did not respond to CNBC's requests for comment, and the company should not let silence stand in for an answer. Shareholders, customers and regulators are entitled to a clear account of who in the company's dealings was connected to Huawei, and what controls existed to catch it.
Regulators should examine the Megaspeed and Hexi chains directly and publish whatever they can. Until they do, the honest reading is that a plausible conflict has surfaced and remains unproven.